Analysis of Factors that Influence Motivation to Pay Zakat, Infaq and Sodaqa (ZIS): Good Governance as Intervening Variable

Ali Ridho; Muhammad Zilal Hamzah; Noor Achmad; Nirdukita Ratnawati; Irfan Syauqi Beik

doi:10.59890/ijasse.v3i1.269

Authors

Ali Ridho Trisakti University
Muhammad Zilal Hamzah Trisakti University
Noor Achmad Wahid Hasyim University
Nirdukita Ratnawati Trisakti University
Irfan Syauqi Beik Bogor Agricultural University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59890/ijasse.v3i1.269

Keywords:

Trust, Professionalism, Religiosity, Ulama, Public Figures, Motivation, Good Governance, ZIS

Abstract

Poverty is a challenging issue that Indonesia and all other countries face. This study uses the zakat, infaq, and alms (ZIS) tools to try to solve this issue. The objective of this study is to examine the elements that affect people's desire to use BAZNAS to pay zakat, infaq, and alms. Given that Indonesia has a big potential for ZIS collection and is one of the countries with a mainly Muslim population, this is an important and fascinating task. The Charity Aid Foundation has ranked Indonesia as the world's most giving nation for seven years running, from 2018 to 2024. The findings indicate that incentives to pay ZIS are significantly impacted by the factors of excellent governance, online payment methods, the role of ulama, and figures, but not by ZIS regulations or income. The research's conclusions can have managerial ramifications for ZIS management organizations and the government, as they can utilize the Islamic qualities of amil-reliability, professionalism, and religion-as requirements for hiring amil. In order to reduce the poverty rate in Indonesia, the ZIS management organization must be able to apply the principles of good governance in its management, work with ulama and figures to persuade and boost public confidence in paying ZIS through BAZNAS, implement an easy and affordable online payment system, and, finally, reevaluate ZIS regulations to make them more effective in collecting zakat, infaq, and alms.

References

Abashidze, A. K., Inshakova, A. O., Solntsev, A. M. and Gugunskiy, D. A. (2021). Socioeconomic inequality as a barrier on the path of sustainable development: “institutional traps” and perspectives of overcoming them. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 41(1–2), 62–75. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJSSP-03-2020-0069.

Abdillah, W. and Jogiyanto. (2015). Partial Least Square (PLS) Alternative Structural Equation Modelling (SEM) dalam Penelitian Bisnis. Ed.1. Yogyakarta: ANDI.

Abd Wahab, N. (2013). Efficiency and Governance of Zakat Institutions in Malaysia, International Islamic University Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur.

Abd Wahab, N. and Rahman, A.R. (2011). Efficiency of zakat institutions and its determinants. 8th International Conference on Islamic Economics and Finance Efficiency, Centre for Islamic Economics and Finance, Qatar Faculty of Islamic Studies, Qatar Foundation, Doha, Qatar, pp. 1-19.

Abdullah, A.A. (1995). Zakat able funds of the state and modes of their collection. in El-Ashker, A.A.F. and Sirajul Haq, M. (Eds), Institutional Framework of Zakat: Dimensions and Implications, Seminar Proceedings No. 23, Islamic Research and Training Institute (IRTI), Islamic Development Bank (IDB), Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, pp. 119-148, available at: www.iefpedia.com/ english/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Institutional-Framework-of-Zakah-Dimensions-and- Implications by- Ahmed-El-Ashker-Sirajul-Haq.pdf (accessed 5 February 2025).

Abioye, V. F., Akande, E. A. and Aluko, B. O. (2014). Effects of Different Local Debittering Methods on Some Chemical Components and Antioxidants in Bitter Leaf (Vernonia amygdalina). International Journal of Research in Chemistry and Environment, 4(1), 96–101.

Abioye, M.M. (2013). Exploratory Study of Nigerian Zakat Institutions and Role of Governance on Zakat. Payers’ Trust, International Islamic University Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur

Adnan, M.A. (2017). The Need of Establishment of Professional Amil Zakat to Enhance the Future Zakat Development. International Journal of Zakat. 2(1) 2017 page 71-79.

Ahmad Soleh. (2017). Strategi Pengembangan Potensi Desa. Jurnal Sungkai Vol.5 No.1, Edisi Februari 2017 Hal : 32-52.

Aifuwa, H.O., Keme, E., and Saidu, N. (2018). Ethical Accounting Practices and Financial Reporting Quality, EPRA International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (IJMR), Volume: 4 | Issue: 12 | December 2018, ISSN (Online): 2455-3662.

Ainun, B., Mahyuni and Silvia, N. (2023). Preferensi Masyarakat dalam Penyaluran Zakat: Tinjauan pada Masyarakat di Kabupaten Banjar. Indonesian Journal of Applied Accounting and Finance Vol. 3, No. 2 (2023), 105-118.

Ajzen, I. & Fishbein, M. (1977). Attitude-Behavior Relations: A Theoretical Analysis and Review of Empirical Research. Psychological Bulletin, 84(5), 888-918.

Al-Jaffri S, R. and Haniffa, R. (2014). Determinants of Zakah (Islamic Tax) Compliance Behavior. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research. Vol. 5 No.2 pp 182-193, doi:10.1108/JIABR-10-2012-0068.

Al-Goaib, S. (2003). Religiosity and social conformity of university students: an Analytical Study Applied at King Saoud University, Arts Journal of King Saoud University, Vol. 16 No. 1.

Al-Omar, F.A. (1990). General, administrative and organizational aspects. in El-Ashker, A.A.F. and Sirajul Haq, M. (Eds), Institutional Framework of Zakat: Dimensions and Implications, Seminar Proceedings No. 23, Islamic Research and Training Institute (IRTI), Islamic Development Bank (IDB), Jeddah, pp. 21-64, available at: www.iefpedia.com/english/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/ Institutional-Framework-of-Zakah-Dimensions-and-Implications-by-Ahmed-El-Ashker-Sirajul- Haq.pdf (accessed 5 Pebruari 2025).

Ascarya, and Yumanita, D. (2018). Analisis Rendahnya Penghimpunan Zakat di Indonesia dan Alternatif Solusinya, Bank Indonesia Working Paper. No. WP/9/2018). Retrieved from Jakarta

Australian Institute of Company Directors. (2013). Good Governance Principles and Guidance for Not-for-Profit Organization, companydirectors.com.au.

Baharits, A.S. and Hasan. (2007). Mendidik Anak Laki-Laki. Depok:Gema Insani Pres

Bakar, N.B. A. and Hafiz, M.A.R. (2010). Motivations of Paying Zakat on Income: Evidence from Malaysia, International Journal of Economics and Finance Vol. 2, No. 3. pp.76-84

Baznas. (2017). Buku Statistik Zakat Nasional 2016, Bagian SIM & Pelaporan Baznas, Jakarta.

Beik, I. S., Hanum, H., Muljawan, D., Yumanita, D., Fiona, A. and Nazar, J. K. (2018). Core Principles for Effective Zakat Supervision: Consultative Document. Jakarta: Bank Indonesia dan Baznas.

Bin-Nashwan, S. A. (2021). Does trust in zakat institution enhance entrepreneurs’ zakat compliance? Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 12(5), 768–790. https://doi.org/10.1108/JIABR-09-2020-0282.

BPS. (2024). Angka Kemiskinan 2024. Badan Pusat Statistik.

Chapra, M. U. (2000). Islam dan Tantangan Ekonomi. Jakarta: Gema Insani

Choudhury, M.A. and Alam, M.M. (2013). Corporate Governance in Islamic perspective, International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management Vol. 6 No. 3, 2013 pp. 180-199.

Choudhury, M. A. (1999). Comperative Economic Theory, Occidental and Islamic Perspective. London: Kluwer Academic Publisher.

Cooper, D. R. and Schindler, P.S. (2003). Business Research Methods. International Edition. New York: McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.

Corbett, A. and Mackay, J. M. (2013). Guide to Good Governance: Not-for-Profit and Charitable Organizations, Second Edition, Governance Center Of Excellent, Ontario.

Darwanis, D., Saputra, M., and Kartini, K. (2016). Effect of Professionalism, Competence, Knowledge of Financial Management, and Intensity Guidance Apparatus Inspectorate for Quality of Financial Statements (Study on Inspectorate Regencies/Cities in Aceh), BRAND. Broad Research in Accounting, Negotiation, and Distribution Volume 7, Issue 1, 2016, ISSN 2067-8177.

Departemen Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan. (1998). Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia. Jakarta: Penerbit Balai Pustaka.

Desky, H. (2016). Analisis faktor-faktor determinan pada motivasi membayar zakat. Jurnal Al-Mabhats- Vol. 1 No. 1. pp.1-11

Donsophon, Konkanok, Prathanporn, J.H. and Saranya R. (2015). Managerial Professionalism Strategy and Firm Success: Empirical Investigation of Hotel Businesses in Thailand AU-GSB E-Journal; Bangkok Vol. 8, Iss. 2, (2015): 141-154

El-Menouar, Yasemin and Stiftung, B. (2014). The Five Dimensions of Muslim Religiosity. Results of an Empirical Study, methods, data, analyses | Vol. 8(1), 2014, pp. 53-78 DOI: 10.12758/mda.2014.003.

Fadiah, F.C.S., Muin, R., Putra, T.W. and Sirajuddin. (2023). Pengaruh kualitas pelayanan dan profesionalisme amil terhadap minat muzaki membayar zakat pada BAZNAS Kabupaten Pinrang. Al-Bayan: Jurnal Hukum dan Ekonomi Islam Vol. 3 No.2, Desember-2023 pp.162-177.

Fadilah, S. (2013). The influence of good governance implementation to organization performance: study on institution Amil Zakat Indonesia”, International Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 15-33.

Fauzi. A. (1997). Psikologi Umum. Bandung: CV. Pustaka Setia.

Gellerman, W. S. (1984). Motivasi dan Produktivitas. penerjemah: Soepomo & Wardoyo. Jakarta: Percetakan Djaya Pirusa.

Ghozali, I. and Latan. H. (2015). Partial Lease Square, konsep, teknik dan aplikasi menggunakan program Smart-Pls 3.0 untuk penelitian empiris. Semarang: Badan Penerbit Universitas Diponegoro (UNIDIP).

Habtoor, N. (2016). Influence of human factors on organisational performance. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 65(4), 460–484. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijppm-02-2014-0016.

Hafidhudin, D. (2002). Zakat dalam Perekonomian Modern. Jakarta: Gema Insani Press.

Hamidiyah, E. (2008). Analisis Faktor-Faktor Yang Mempengaruhi Pengumpulan Zakat, Infak, Shadaqah, Wakaf Dan Kurban Pada Lembaga Pengelola Zakat (Studi Kasus: Dompet Dhuafa’ Republika). Jurnal EKSIS (Ekonomi Islam Dan Bisnis Islam) Vol. 4, No. 1. pp. 120-135

Hidayat, A. & Muhklisin. (2020). Analisis Pertumbuhan Zakat Pada Aplikasi Zakat Online Dompet Dhuafa. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Islam. Vol 6 No. 3 hal 675-684.

Hsubky, B. (1995). Dilema Ulama Dalam Perubahan Zaman. Jakarta:Gema Insani Press.

Ibanez, M. B., Serio, A. D., Villarán, D. and Kloos, C. D. (2016). Support for augmented reality simulation systems: The effects of scaffolding on learning outcomes and behavior patterns. Transactions on Learning Technologies, 3(1), 1-12. http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TLT.2015.2445761.

Isnaini. (2018). Pengaruh Internalsiasi Maqasid Syariah Terhadap Keputusan Membayar ZISpada Pengelola Zakat Melalui Pemasaran Sosial. Disertasi Doktor, Program Doktor Ilmu Ekonomi-Islamic Economics and Finance, Universitas Trisakti Jakarta.

Kamal, M. E. M., Salleh, M. F. M. and Ahmad, A. (2016). Detecting financial statement fraud by Malaysian public listed companies: The reliability of the Beneish M-Score model. Jurnal Pengurusan (UKM Journal of Management), Vol. 46. pp. 23-32

Kartika, I. (2020). Pengaruh Pendapatan Terhadap Minat Membayar Zakat Dengan Kesadaran Sebagai Variabel Intervening (Studi Kasus Muzaki di BAZNAS Salatiga). Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Islam ISSN: 2477-6157, 6(01), 42-52.

Kanji, L., Habbe, A. H. and Mediaty. (2011). Faktor-faktor Determinan Motivasi Membayar Zakat (Determinant Factors Motivations Paying Zakat and MagnitudeValue): Tesis Universitas Hasanuddin Makassar.

Kaslam, S. (2009). Governing zakat as a social institution: the Malaysian perspective, Social and Management Research Journal, Vol. 6 No. 1, pp. 15-32.

Kim, J. and Daniel, S. (2016). Religion and Corporate Governance: Evidence from 32 Countries, Asia Pacific Journal of Financial Studies, https://doi.org/10.1111/ajfs.12130.

Kretiner, R. d. (2008). Organizational Behavior. 8th Edition. Boston: McGraw Hill

Ladewi, Y., Supriadi, T., Sjam, J. M. E., Welly, A. and Subowo, H. (2021). Akuntabilitas dan Transparansi Pengelolaan Dana Desa. Jurnal Penelitian, 28(2), 45–64. https://ejournal.undiksha.ac.id/index.php/JPPSH/article/view/33246.

Latan, H. and Ghozali, I. (2017). Partial Least Squares, Konsep, Metode dan Aplikasi, Program WarpPLS 5.0. Semarang: Badan Penerbit Universitas Diponegoro.

Linda, H. Y., Hsieh and Suzana, B. R. (2014). Revisiting the Trustworthiness– Performance–Governance Nexus in International Joint Ventures, Management International Review, Springer, Vol. 54(5), pages 675-705, October.

Mahdavikhou, M. and Mohsen, K. (2011). The Impact of Professional Ethics on Financial Reporting Quality, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(11): 2092-2096, 2011, ISSN 1991-8178.

Mamatzakis, E. and Bermpei, T. (2016). What is the effect of unconventional monetary policy on bank performance? Journal of International Money and Finance, 67, 239–263. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jimonfin.2016.05.005.

Mangkunegara, A. A. A. P. (2005). Evaluasi Sumber Daya Manusia. Bandung: Refika Aditama.

Marbun, B.N. (2003). Kamus Manajemen. Jakarta: Pustaka Sinar Harapan.

Mariyanti,T. (2011). Faktor Sosial Ekonomi yang Mempengaruhi Penurunan Kemiskinan di Indonesai dalam Perspektif Islam. Disertasi Doktor, Program Doktor Ilmu Ekonomi-Islamic Economics and Finance, Universitas Trisakti Jakarta.

Marzano, R. J., Pickering, D. and McTighe, J. (1993). Assessing Student Outcomes: Performance Assessment Using the Dimensions of Learning Model. Association for Supervision & Curriculum Dev.

Mayer, R.C., James H. D. and Schoorman, F.D. (1995). An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust, The Academy of Management Review, Vol. 20, No. 3 (Jul. 1995), pp. 709-734, Published by Academy of Management Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/258792.

McDaniel, S. W. and Burnett, J. J. (1990). Consumer Religiosity and Retail Store Evaluative Criteria. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 18(2), 101– 112.

Miriam, B. (1972). Dasar-dasar ilmu politik. Jakarta. PT. Gramedia Pustaka.

Mollering, G. (2002). Perceived trustworthiness and inter‐firm Governance: Empirical Evidence from the U.K. Printing Industry. Cambridge Journal of Economics, Volume 26, Issue 2, March 1, 2002, Pages 139-160.

Mufti, A. and Sula, M. S. (2007). Konsep Ekonomi Syariah. Jakarta: Masyarakat Ekonomi Syariah.

Muhammad, S.A. and Saad, R.A.J. (2016). Determinants of trust on zakat institutions and its dimensions on intention to pay zakat: a pilot study. Journal of Advanced Research in Business and Management Studies. Vol. 3 No. 1, pp. 40-46.

Mujiyana, and Elissa, I. (2013). Analisis Yang Mempengaruhi Keputusan Pembelian Via Internet Melalui Toko Online. Jurnal Undip, Vol VIII, No 3, September 2013.

Muliati, and Rasyid, C. (2019). Persepsi masyarakat terhadap kesadaran muzaki dalam membayar zakat di Kabupaten Pinrang. Diktum-jurnal Syariah dan Hukum. Vol. 17 No.1 pp.128-150.

Nasution, M.E., Huda, N., Setyanto, Mufraini and Utama. (2006). Pengenalan Eksklusif Ekonomi Islam. Jakarta: Kencana.

Neliwati, Rizal, S. and Hemawati. (2022). Peranan tokoh agama dalam meningkatkan motivasi pelaksanaan keagamaan masyarakat. Jurnal pendidikan agama Islam. Volume 9 No. 01.

Noor, A.H.M. (2012). Assessing performance of nonprofit organization: a framework for zakat institutions, British Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 1, pp. 12-22, doi: 10.1613/jair.301.

Nugroho D, R. (2004). Kebijakan Publik, Formulasi, Implementasi dan Evaluasi. Jakarta: Gramedia.

Olufadi, Y. (2016). Muslim Daily Religiosity Assessment Scale (MUDRAS): A New Instrument for Muslim Religiosity Research and Practice. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality. Advance online publication. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/rel0000074.

Pirac.org (Public Interest Research and Advocacy Center). (2007). Pola dan Potensi Sumbangan Masyarakat. Survey Rumah Tangga di 11 Kota Besar, diakses 18/04/2008.

Powelt, R. (2009). Zakat: drawing insights for legal theory and economic policy from Islamic jurisprudence. Pittsburgh Tax Review, Vol. 43 No. 7, pp. 42-101.

Puskas BAZNAS. (2022). Outlook zakat Indonesia 2022. BAZNAS.

Puskas BAZNAS. (2024). Outlook zakat Indonesia 2024. BAZNAS.

Qardawi, Y. (2002). Zakat Role in Curing Social and Economic Malaises. In Kahf, M (Ed). Economics of Zakat. Jeddah: IRTI-IDB.

Qardawi, Y. (2013). Fiqhu Al Zakat. Maktabah Wahbah.

Rahmaningtyas, W. and Widagdo, P. R. (2020). Pengaruh Kompensasi, Motivasi Kerja, dan Lingkungan Kerja Fisik Terhadap Kepuasan Kerja. Economic Education Analysis Journal. EEAJ. 9 (3). 679- 689.

Ramadhan, F.H. and Triono, F.R. (2022). Pengaruh online payment terhadap minat untuk berzakat online. Al-Intaj-Jurnal Ekonomi dan Perbankan Syariah. Vol. 8 No. 2. pp 139-151.

Reksoprayitno. (2004). Sistem Ekonomi dan Demokrasi Ekonomi. Jakarta: Bina Grafika.

Rizkia, A. S. (2014). Pengaruh Faktor Budaya, Motivasi, Regulasi dan Pemahaman Tentang Zakat Terhadap Keputusan Muzaki untuk Membayar Zakat Mall. Jurnal Telaah & Riset Akuntansi Vol. 7 No. 1.pp 29-38

Ridlwan, A. A. and Sukmana, R. (2017). The Determinant Factors of Motivation to Pay Zakat in Regional Amil Zakat Agency of East Java. Karsa: Journal of Social and Islamic Culture ISSN: 2442-3289 (p); 2442-8285 (e), Vol. 25 No.2, December 2017, pp. 334-345

Ross, M., Perkins, H. and Bodey, K. (2016). Library & Information Science Research Academic motivation and information literacy self-efficacy : The importance of a simple desire to know, 38, 2–4.

Saad, R. A. J. and Haniffa, R. (2014). Determinants of zakat (Islamic tax) compliance behavior. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 5(2), 182–193. https://doi.org/10.1108/JIABR-10-2012-0068.

Said, J., Ghani, E., Zawawi, S. and Yusof, S. (2012). Composite performance measurement for zakat organisations. British Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Sciences, Vol. 4 No. 1, pp. 50-59, doi: 10.1007/s13398-014-0173-7.2.

Samuelson, A.P. (1992). Ekonomi Makro. Jakarta: Erlangga.

Saputra, R.E. (2024. 19 November). Indonesia Kembali Dinobatkan Jadi Negara Paling Dermawan di Dunia 2024. Diakases pada 24 November 2024, dari https://www.tempo.co/video/arsip/indonesia-kembali-dinobatkan-jadi-negara-paling-dermawan-di-dunia-2024-1170535.

Sariyanti. (2019). Pengaruh Implementasi Prinsip Good Corporate Governance terhadap Motivasi Masyarakat Membayar Zakat di Baznas Kota Bandar Lampung. Thesis Program Pasca Sarjana UIN Raden Intan Lampung.

Sari, C. A. (2015). Perilaku Berbelanja Online Di Kalangan Mahasiswi Antropologi Universitas Airlangga. AntroUnairdotNet. Vol. 4. No. 2. pp.205 – 216).

Sawmar, A.A. and Mohammed, M.O. (2021). Enhancing zakat compliance through good governance: a conceptual framework. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance Vol. 13 No. 1, 2021 pp. 136-154 Emerald Publishing Limited 0128-1976 DOI 10.1108/IJIF-10-2018-0116.

Schulte, K.W. (2009). Corporate Governance in The Real Estate Industry, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287698746_Corporate_Governance_ in_the_Real_Estate_Industry. DOI: 10.1002/9781444315301.ch12.

Sekaran, U. and Bougie, R. (2013). Research Methods for Business A Skill –Building Approach Six Edition. United Kingdom: John Wiley & Sons LTD.

Setia, M. and Zulkifli. (2018). Pengaruh Penerapan Coporate Governance (GCG) dan Budaya Organisasi Pengelola Zakat terhadap Motivasi Pembayaran Zakat Penghasilan di DIY. Jurnal Kajian Bisnis , Vol 26 (1). Pp. 48-68.

Shafer, W. E., Park, L.J. and Woody M. L. (2002). Professionalism, Organizational-professional conflict and Work outcomes, A Study of certified Management Accountant, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 15 No. 1, 2002, pp. 46-63.

Shahul, H.M.I. (2000). The need for Islamic accounting: Perception of Malaysian Muslims accountants and academicians on the objectives and characteristics of Islamic accounting. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis. University of Dundee, UK.

Shaikh, S.A. (2015). Welfare Potential of Zakat: An Attempt to Estimate Economy-wide Zakat Collection in Pakistan, The Pakistan Development Review 54:4, Part II pp. 1011–1027.

Stewart, J. and Walsh, K. (1992). Change In the Management of Public Services. Public Administration, 70(4), 499–518.

Sudjiman, P. (1961). Memahami cerita rekaan. Jakarta: Dunia pustaka jaya.

Surbakti. (1992). Memahami ilmu politik. Jakarta: PT. Grasindo.

Syafei, Z. (2015). Public trust of zakat management in the office of religious affairs, Cipocok Jaya, Serang, Banten, Indonesia. Journal of Management and Sustainability. Vol. 5 No. 3 pp. 155-164.

Syauqi, M., Anshori, M. and Mawardi, I. (2022). Motivation to paying Zakat: The role of religiosity, Zakat literacy, and government regulations. al-Uqud: Journal of Islamic Economics Volume 06 Issue 02, 6(2), 232–246. https://doi.org/10.26740/aluqud.v6n2.p232-246

Taha, R., Adam, F., Ali, N. M. and Ariff, A.M. (2017). Religiosity and Transparency in the Management of Zakat Institutions. Journal of Legal. Ethical and Regulatory Issues Volume 20, Issue 1, 1-9.

Taylor, D. (2014). Governance for not-for-profit organizations: questions for directors, Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada, Toronto, www.cpacanada.ca.

Teoh, W. M. Y., Choy, C.S., Lin, B. and Wei. C. J. (2013). Factors affecting consumers perception of electronic payment: an empirical analysis. Internet Research. Vol. 23 Iss 4 pp. 465 – 485.

Nofianti, Leny and Suseno, N.S. (2014). Factors affecting implementation of good government governance (GGG) and their implications towards performance accountability, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 164 (2014) 98 – 105.

Wahab, A.S. (2002). Analisis Kebijaksanaan, dari Formulasi ke Implementasi Kebijaksanaan Negara. Jakarta: Sinar Grafika.

Wahab, N. A. and Rahim, A.R.A. (2011). A framework to analyse the efficiency and governance of institutions. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 2(1), 43–62.

Zahrah, N., Hamid, S. N. A., Rani, S. A. and Kamil, B.A.M. (2016). Enhancing Job Performance through Islamic Religiosity and Islamic Work Ethics, International Review of Management and Marketing Vol 6 No. 7, 185-198. ISSN: 2146-4405.

Zein, I. M., Al-Ahsan, Abdullah and Arif, Z.M. (2008). Qur’anic Guidance on Good Governance, Dalam Al-Ahsan. Abdullah and Young, Stephen B. (Eds). Guidance For Good Governance, Explorations in Qur’anic, Scientific and Cross-Cultural Approaches, Kuala Lumpur: IIUM Press.

Zullig, K. J., Ward, R. M. and Horn, T. (2006). The Association Between Perceived Spirituality, Religiosity, and Life Satisfaction: The mediating role of self-rated health. Social Indicators Research, 79(2), 255–274.